Let’s get this out of the way first: Big Red is a boy-meets-dog story in which the dog doesn’t die in the end. That won’t come as much of a surprise once you begin reading, because Big Red, like his seventeen-year-old trainer Danny, is a survivor.
This book was originally published in 1945, and the publisher’s blurb read:
“Big Red” was a champion Irish setter; Danny a young trapper who knew more about the ways of varmints and hounds than of the world of fancy kennels and dog shows. But Red’s owner knew a good dog man when he saw one, and entrusted Red to Danny’s training.
I read this book many times while growing up, and I enjoyed it. But reading it again this year, I realized just how much rugged goodness I had taken for granted.
The “young trapper” Danny and his father live in a shack in the Wintapi, New York, wilderness. They squatted there years before the vast acreage was bought up by Mr. Haggin, and they live there still under an agreement in which Mr. Haggin allows them free run of the forest, requiring only that they leave the most valuable timber uncut.
Danny’s father, Ross, is a widower and poor by nearly any standard. But as a woodsman, he supports himself without needing anything he cannot earn from the wilderness. Hunting, trapping, fishing, foraging, and husbandry are his daily life, and he has passed these skills on to Danny. The two of them live in a harmonic interdependence–each determinedly self-reliant, seeking to be the giver rather than the recipient, yet easily accepting from one another the services they cannot perform for themselves.
I love the way Kjelgaard makes plain the love between father in son, and that they are both aware of this love, without either of them needing to say it aloud. I was struck by Ross’ stubborn respect for Danny’s decisions, even when he feels hurt by them, and by Danny’s sincere desire to please his dad even when his conscience prevents it.
Mr. Haggin quickly becomes the second-most influential person in the Danny’s life. Throughout the story, the wealthy man’s most notable characteristic is the dignity with which he treats every creature he touches. Mr. Haggin is not a soft man, but it’s his pragmatic brand of generosity that allows the story to happen at all.
An Irish Setter might seem like a strange companion for a deep-woods trapper, because it is. Setters are show dogs and bird-hunting dogs; trappers are best served by hounds. But Red (Mr. Haggin’s dog) is a beautiful animal whose perfection Danny intuitively understands and loves. The tension between their separate estates drives much of the story’s conflict and character growth. Love brings boy and dog together, but it is Danny’s willingness to change that binds them.
Old Majesty is an enormous, almost-mythical specimen of a black bear. He fills the role of Monster In The Dark, an impossible dragon for the hero to slay. He is an early influence drawing Danny, Red, and Mr. Haggin together. He provides the greatest threat to, and ultimately the fulfillment of, Danny’s dreams. Most of all, Old Majesty embodies the untamed, destructive, yet untainted power of the wilderness where Danny lives.
The seasons change several times over the course of this story, and Kjelgaard allows us to see, hear, smell, and taste a forest very like the one where I grew up. It is clear that he lived in, and loved, a place nearby; he describes flora and fauna, hill and stream, with the insight of a practical naturalist. As I read Big Red this time, it was pleasant to see how the author used the steady steps of the men, the dog, and the bear as stitches that sew together the changing moods of his wilderness setting. Big Red is a book of hardscrabble virtue and I think it should be part of every boy’s life.
- Escape Into Reality: Jack Zulu and the Waylander’s Key - January 30, 2023
- Rascal, by Sterling North - January 19, 2022
- Playing (Your Own) Role - January 17, 2022
Amanda Cleary Eastep says
Wonderful reflections and an encouragement to us grown-ups to re-read the stories that shaped us. I wonder if what you defined as a “taking for granted” was simply a limited perspective. I’ve found that with the best children’s books, and even with Scripture, one of the reasons they are so inherently good and wise and valuable is because they speak ageless truths that we understand differently at different times in our lives. If a good book is like a jewel, then I can appreciate it as a whole while sometimes observing different facets or characteristics. So while A Wrinkle in Time, the Chronicles of Narnia, and From the Mixed-Up Files of Mrs. Basil E. Frankweiler didn’t hold the same sparkle when I re-read them as an adult, they did reinforce my love of story and of “whatever is good” and of almost magic. And (to Madeleine L’Engle’s thoughts on aging), they spoke differently to all the ages I have ever been. Big Red sounds like a wonderful book. Thank you for sharing it, James.
James D. Witmer says
Well, I was a very long time discovering your comment, but I appreciate it nonetheless! I think you’re right about how our appreciation changes over time, without necessarily growing any less. Thank you, Amanda!